Grading Criteria for Written Letters

points: 4 = Superior 3 = Good 2 = Mediocre 1 = Deficient

Content

• Attention to the Assignment. Does the letter contain all the elements specified in the assignment?
• Argument. Does the paper have a main point? Is there a clear and logical progression of ideas expanding on that main point?
• Evidence. Is the argument supported by an adequate number of concrete facts and vivid details? Are points well enough developed to be convincing?
• Research. Are there enough high-quality sources? Are facts and theories from these sources presented accurately?

Total for Content _______

Writing Style

• Words. Are all words spelled correctly and chosen wisely? Has the writer avoided jargon?
• Sentences. Are grammar and syntax correct? Can the reader easily understand what is being said?
• Paragraph organization. Are sentences varied in length and smoothly connected? Are paragraphs unified, coherent, and fully developed? Does the letter flow from beginning to end?
• Mechanics. Is the letter correctly presented? Are sources properly cited in the letter? Is the plan accurately explained?

Total for Writing Style _______

Total Score for Letter _______ (48 Possible)

Grade for Paper _________